4.3"Good News for People Who Loves Bad News"

[Hilarie Burton]

Lucas and Brooke, now broken up, clash at a post-game party and Haley realizes that Rachel is plotting to seduce Nathan. Meanwhile, Peyton connects with her half-brother, Rachel reveals that she knows who is pregnant and Skills takes the court with the Ravens basketball team.









Okay..Another great episode! I was so happy!! I thought that Derrick was really hott..though I don't kthink he's her brother. I'm thinking he's just some creppy guy who watches her webcam and listens to her podcasts, and faked to be Derrick. I mean, I liked when they were hanging out and all, but then that end was soo creppy!! OMG..

Okay, I know everyone is going to go "Eww!", but when Karen went to see Dan in the middle of the night, when he opened the door, I went "Woaah!". He looked hott!! I know..he's old. lol But I don't know what it was..he just looked hott. Yes! I said it..I thought Dan looked hott last night!

I thought Brookes line to Peyton about Ellie was waaaaay crossing the line. I wasn't happy about that. I thought it was funny when she kissed Derek and goes "Oh, don't worry, it will only make her like you more." I was like..omg. Then I loved the look on Peytons face when she told Brooke he was her brother. It was like the "You're an idiot" look. lol

I think Haley/Joy (whoever you want to say) needs a new hair style. OMG! Any scene with her in it, I couldn't stop staring at it!! It's soooo wild and unmaintained! Ugh...Honestly, Peyton and Brooke look so nice! I loved Peyton's hair last night..and they way her makeup is done is so pretty! I love it. And Brooke always looks beautiful. I don't know..that's just my opinion.

I thought it was kind of sad when Haley asked Nathan if he liked Rachel. She was kind of crushed. You could tell by the look on her face. Though, it was all better when she asked if she had a small head! haha..That was so funny. Rachel has the most random comebacks.

I loved the Brooke/Rachel fight scene. I thought it was great!!! They both have great comebacks, so they were a great match for eachother. The look on Mouth's face was priceless!! He was shocked.

I'm still not convinced it's Brooke who's pregnant. I think it's Haley.

What did everyone else think?

[naleylove4ever]

I agree. Great episode.

Derek was totally creepy at the end. I was like, "What a freak!" It reminded me of One Hour Photo with Robin Williams.

Brooke's comment about Peyton's mom was uncalled for, but I think she redeemed herself in the end by sticking up for Haley and Nathan, at least in my opinion. I hope Brooke will be there for Haley.

LOL about Dan! I agree, he didn't look half bad. I think it's funny that you said that because I thought he looked hot in season 2 when he was recovering from his heart attack and had the stuble growing on his face. Dan is not a bad looking man, he's just a jerk.

I think Haley/Joy always looks gorgeous! It just goes to show that nobody's perfect and you don't have to have beautiful hair for someone to like you. I'm sure it'll get better looking as the season progresses, but in my opinion, I think it's beautiful like it always has been.

The Naley scene at the end was so sweet. Haley shouldn't even have to think that her husband likes someone else, but Nathan's needing some answers about the accident, so I guess he'll get what he needs from Rachel, but I feel so sad for Haley. I wanted to jump up and down though when Nathan showed Rachel his ring and was like, "Think again" or whatever he said to prove that he's not interested in her. And I almost jumped up and down again when Nathan brought the bracelet back! That was a happy moment!

Anyways, great episode and I hope next week is just as good.

[Hilarie Burton]

Haha...I chucked when I read your "They should stalk eachother" line. lol

I don't know if Brooke really redeemed herself in my eyes. I'm glad she's sticking up for the people she loved, but I think she has to do something for Peyton.

HAHA!! Dan's not a bad looking guy!! At least I'm not the only one who thinks so!

And regarding Haley/Joys hair- The actor/actress have NO say about what their hair or clothes or make-up or anything like that for an episode. It's all up to Mark Schwann. I was watching this one interview where Joy thought Haley should have her hair scrunched, so her hair person did it, and when Mark saw it, he like...flipped out. That wasn't a bad remark against Joy...She is beautiful. It was more of a remark toward Mark and her hair dresser person .

Aww!! The braclet was great!! I like, jumped up when he gave it to Haley...So sweet! I also liked when Nathan said "Guess again!" I went "o0o0! Burnn!!" lol

I like Rachel in there...I think she causes good drama...That's why she's on! I mean, the writers have us talking about and wanting to tune in next week, so they are obviously doing their job right!

[naleylove4ever]

You have some very good points about the actors' hair But why would Mark want to have an actor with unmaintained hair? I don't know. I miss season 1 Naley when they had no troubles (well, except maybe porn , but I guess that's why I keep watching, to see them get through their problems together.

[Sophia Bush]

it was awesome....and i think it is very possible that it is haley thats pregnant..cause notice how brooke never said "i'm pregnant"......i least i think she never did



and i agree about joy's hair.....it nice and long....but its so wild and frizzy.....and she needs to make a decision weather she wants it straight or curly..cause its kinda in the middle all the time and it looks bad......Brooke's hair is nice...and i love love love peyton's hair....i like it darker..and i like how its curls but not the tight curls that we are used to seeing on her

[Bethany Joy Galeotti]

I love Joy's Hair now. I really do. they Lighten her Hair more and all but i miss her Season three Straight Hair. I just loved it. But this Hair Style isn't so bad!

Yea. I'am hoping that she is Pregnant. But who knows that. It's So Confussing. but I'm going to go with the Spoiler on Fanforum.

[Hilarie Burton]

I miss her straightened hair, too. I love it that way. It looks so pretty!