Naley

[Sophia Bush]

okay in the beginning of this season i couldn't stand nathan(i forgive him now) it just broke my heart the way he was treating haley and how their realationship was going down...what do you guys think?

[Bethany Joy Galeotti]

I love Haley to dealth i really do. But unless you had your heart broken you do not know how it feels. I understand what Nathan went through. He had never loved anyone (Even Peyton) So deeply. than for Haley to walk out like that it tore him apart. I think anyone would agree. Leaving with Chris like Haley did. It was a huge Mistake. I know lots of people hate her now for that one huge Mistake she did do. But you learn and live. Plus Nathan and Haley where so young when they got married. I think that had alot to do with it. I think a year later there older and more Wiser.

[Hilarie Burton]

I agree. I hated Haley, not Nathan. Haley was in the wrong, Nathan didn't do anything. If someone walked out on me and just expected to be forgiven, I would treat them badly, too!! It was a HUGE mistake that she made, not him. So don't hate on Nathan, if anything, hate on Haley. But, I still like Haley and all, but then I didn't.

[Bethany Joy Galeotti]

One thing i didn't understand, Nathan wanted to go one tour he would have if she asked. So my Question is why didn't she just bring him with her ? If only for a week or 2 ?

[Hilarie Burton]

Yeah, really!! I mean, he even made that as a point. She's not going for Chris or anything like that...just the music. Well than why didn't she ask him to come with her. Good point...It would have solved A LOT of problems!

[Sophia Bush]

ya....but she didn't want him there with Chris i guess...cause they hate each other....and she probably was really confused.........i was really confused watching the episode on what she should do...and i think u r right about the whole age thing.......if they waited longer to get married they would have each been able to follow their dreams

[Hilarie Burton]

Yeah, but then they may not have been able to stay together....You can't really play 'What if' though...They did what they did, and that's that.

[babyjamesismine25]

okayy well..

i have a VERY big opinion on this "situation" lol

i do not like haley.. at all.
i liked her in the beginning of the first season when she was bff's with luke and she was all happy and bubbley..

now i hate her..

first off she should not have left nathan like that. nathan had given up high fliers for her without even telling her -- he didn't even have to think about it and then knowing this she runs off on tour?! and then seriously, if she had asked nate to go with her she probably could have avoided all the drama.. honestly. it was so dumb of her because then it makes it seem like it was more about chris.

i liked haley a lot until this whole thing happened, but i just can't forgive her for that. idk how nathan found the stregnth to do it quite honestly. i don't think she deserves him.

[Hilarie Burton]

babyjamesismine25 said:

okayy well..

i have a VERY big opinion on this "situation" lol

i do not like haley.. at all.
i liked her in the beginning of the first season when she was bff's with luke and she was all happy and bubbley..

now i hate her..

first off she should not have left nathan like that. nathan had given up high fliers for her without even telling her -- he didn't even have to think about it and then knowing this she runs off on tour?! and then seriously, if she had asked nate to go with her she probably could have avoided all the drama.. honestly. it was so dumb of her because then it makes it seem like it was more about chris.

i liked haley a lot until this whole thing happened, but i just can't forgive her for that. idk how nathan found the stregnth to do it quite honestly. i don't think she deserves him.

I agree 100%!! I really love the very last sentence, too.

[haley]

babyjamesismine25 said:

okayy well..

i have a VERY big opinion on this "situation" lol

i do not like haley.. at all.
i liked her in the beginning of the first season when she was bff's with luke and she was all happy and bubbley..

now i hate her..

first off she should not have left nathan like that. nathan had given up high fliers for her without even telling her -- he didn't even have to think about it and then knowing this she runs off on tour?! and then seriously, if she had asked nate to go with her she probably could have avoided all the drama.. honestly. it was so dumb of her because then it makes it seem like it was more about chris.

i liked haley a lot until this whole thing happened, but i just can't forgive her for that. idk how nathan found the stregnth to do it quite honestly. i don't think she deserves him.

I dont not agree at all. I have to stick up for Haley (Cause no one else well) Haley had this Chance that anyone would take if they could. Yes haley made a mistake, Hell she was young and Foolish i'm not saying that she did the right thing, But She wanted to do something for her once in her life. I dont think anyone can say they wouldn't do the same thing. She got this chance To do something she believed that she was good at So i dont Fault Haley at all. I dont really like what she did but she did it and Well it's the past some people are going to continue to hate her for that some might not. That what she got for taking a Chance.

[Sophia Bush]

haley said:

babyjamesismine25 said:

okayy well..

i have a VERY big opinion on this "situation" lol

i do not like haley.. at all.
i liked her in the beginning of the first season when she was bff's with luke and she was all happy and bubbley..

now i hate her..

first off she should not have left nathan like that. nathan had given up high fliers for her without even telling her -- he didn't even have to think about it and then knowing this she runs off on tour?! and then seriously, if she had asked nate to go with her she probably could have avoided all the drama.. honestly. it was so dumb of her because then it makes it seem like it was more about chris.

i liked haley a lot until this whole thing happened, but i just can't forgive her for that. idk how nathan found the stregnth to do it quite honestly. i don't think she deserves him.

I dont not agree at all. I have to stick up for Haley (Cause no one else well) Haley had this Chance that anyone would take if they could. Yes haley made a mistake, Hell she was young and Foolish i'm not saying that she did the right thing, But She wanted to do something for her once in her life. I dont think anyone can say they wouldn't do the same thing. She got this chance To do something she believed that she was good at So i dont Fault Haley at all. I dont really like what she did but she did it and Well it's the past some people are going to continue to hate her for that some might not. That what she got for taking a Chance.

i agree with Haley James Scott




........i mean this was her one chance to follow her dreams.....she was just trying to do something for herself....i think she was confused because she didn't want to hurt Nathan...but at the same time she wanted to do something for her music(which nathan totally supported her music) i dont really think it is fair to hold that against her. She was always miss help everyone else and she does one thing foe herself and everyone is mad?? i just dont understand.

sure she left her marriage.....but that was in anthans eyes...its not like she left him to be with Chris...she was there for her music and then came home to Nathan. She said it herslef "There wasn't one time that i was on tour that my heart wasn't with you". She said it wasn't worth anything because he wasn't with her. i was kind of shocked that she left in the beginning. But they worked it all out because they are in love.

[Hilarie Burton]

Yeah, Haley was following her dreams and all, but she left Nathan. I don't hate Haley, but I'm still not 100% over what she did to Nathan. Well, we are all going to back up who we like more....

[haley]

I agree. I mean all the Characters did some things but am sure you well always like Certain one's. No matter what. It's the same way with anyone you like really.

[Hilarie Burton]

Yeah, exactly!

[Sophia Bush]

ya you'll always stand behind your fav Character